|
|
Religious Book Store > Religious books beginning with P
|
Pope Joan: A Novel |
Author: Donna Cross
Published: 1996 |
List price: $14.95
Our price: $10.17
|
Usually ships in 24 hours
As of: December 03rd, 2008 06:12:07 PM
|
|
|
Customer comments on this selection.
 Little Hope for Joan the Pope
I was eager to read this book for I was expecting an exacting, honest account of a female pope and her trials . . . well the book delivers the factoids and that's about it. In the hands of a more deft author, this book could have dazzled its readers. But, unfortunately, it comes across as silly and adolescent.
 I believe
"Let her copy the behavior of a dog who always has his heart and his eye upon his master: even if his master whip him and throw stones at him." That is an excerpt from the book. It was in a wedding ceremony, spoken to the bride of course. What a lovely time that must have been to be a woman! I liked this book very much due mostly to the fact it is about an amazingly strong, courageous, and gutsy woman. She struggled like no other heroine I have yet read about. The first half of the book has more personality and really focuses on her, her thoughts, her feelings, and her trials. The last half of the book bored me to tears in some places, as it tends to go on and on about the papacy and a lot of war. That was the times and what was occuring during that part of her life, but I wish it had a more personal feel like the first half of the book. NOTE: be aware this is very controversial and when you are overheard discussing it with your close buddy, some very opinated, know it all male is going to butt in and give his two cents and deny her existence. To each their own I say. I BELIEVE.
I was surprised that I loved this book
This book is not the typical book for me, I like murder mysteries, forensic studies, etc. I was given the book by a co-worker to read. I enjoyed it immensely, as a matter of fact I could barely put it down. The only reason I did put it down is the print was so small, my eyes grew weary. I finally purchased a page sized magnifier to get through it. Most intriguing read.
 Anachronisms and Axes to Grind
A number of reviewers here have noted the protagonist's jarringly modern feminist philosophy, some with a good deal of disdain. Speaking as a feminist, I find the anachronism irritating for the opposite reason some of these people dislike it. Many are annoyed by what they see as propaganda or polticial correctnes, but *everyone* who notes the problem sees at least one thing in common: this modern mindset is simply inappropriate to the setting.
There is a trope now, of proto-feminist Mary Sue characters, paragons of virtue, intellect, and (pointlessly) physical beauty. Understanding why this tempted authors at one time doesn't excuse it years and years into the trend. It's lazy writing, and dishonest philosophizing, to set female characters outside their time (why write about any given period, only to stay outside it?). I see no benefit in telling tales of characters who are now so easily identifiable as frauds. I also see little point in inventing avalanches of abuses for such characters to endure; this sort of thing tips easily into ludicrousness.
Life on its own real terms would have been difficult for any woman in Pope Joan's (purported) period. Manufacturing drama misses that very plain point, and dismisses the weight of reality. Likewise, overstating the perfections of a female character implicitly questions the value of real, flawed womanhood. More to the point, for a book review: it makes for tedious, weak, shallow writing.
As others have also noted, the religious prejudices are thick and oppressive throughout this novel. I'm not Catholic, but Cross's apparent resentment against the Church is distracting and offputting. There are places in which story feels replaced by screed, and token attempts to create (minutely) sympathetic characters fail to achieve any balance.
You can do a blade disservice by grinding it too hard. A dull axe is a poor weapon to wield.
 WOW!
I must say, I started reading this for book club and had no idea as to the subject matter. Even though it is titled Pope Joan, in my mind, I assumed this was a historical fiction account of Joan of Arc. Boy did I get my Joans confused! I loved this book and learned so much. I had never heard of Pope Joan and am so glad I did. Her character, spirit, wit and knowledge kept me rooting for her the whole way. Reminiscint of Shield of Three Lions by Pamela Kaufman.
|
|
Our Religious book picks:
|
|
Search the Religious Products Store
LCS Amazon Store 2.5 © 2008
|
|
|